Are you certain you're handing in (for each item):
Hands, Arms, Bracers, Helm:
- 1x Pattern for the slot,
- 1x ornate material for your class (leather, plate, silk or chain
- and 1x token/emblem for your class (purchased from Murgot)
- Total of 3 items
Legs, Chest:
- The same as above but you must use 2x ornate material for your class, not 1
- Total of 4 items
This specific wiki post isn't particularly clear in listing the items you need (in fact, the only part of the wiki entry that is explicit is the copied quest text from Murgort himself, as this is the part that explains you need to buy the emblem from Murgot to tell him what class you want the item for).
Namely:
"To reforge the ornate armor, you need
three things:
an emblem of your profession class, which you can purchase from me,
an appropriate armor piece pattern, and the
ornate crafting material appropriate to your armor class. if you wear cloth type armor, you need to use Ornate Silk, if you wear leather, you need Ornate Leather, if you wear chain, you need Ornate Metal Rings, and finally, if you wear heavy plate, you need ornate metal Sheets.
You need just 1 of the ornate material per each armor pattern, with exception of the legs and chest parts, which require 2. Bring me all the required parts, and I will reforge the armor for you."