The Hidden Forest

Name of character: Niix / Grussum
Class of character: Nec / War
Is in a group: Yes
Is in a raid: Yes
Has a Bot spawned: No
Zone: DSK 3
Nature of Bug:
DSK 3 mobs appear to have the HP / Damage they had before the overall tone down of raid mobs. On Valik, I can normally run him with one cleric and healing automation for heals even without a slow. Although healing automation is not working I had him slowed with 2 clerics, shaman and druid healing and still hit 40% a couple of times. Can also normally kill him with 2 events. I was still at 30% after 2 even with druid bp which I don't have on live.

Maestro - can normally tank him with just one cleric healing and shaman slowed. Had an extra cleric and druid on tank and still died. Also I average 2 spawns or within 10% when the 3rd spawns.

Per logs the max hit that Maestro is getting is over 4x what it is on live -

Grussum - War - Defender's Guard 3 - AC 17666

Live - max hit I see is 1617

[Sat Jun 13 23:55:19 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:19 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:21 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:22 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:22 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:22 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:22 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:23 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:23 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:25 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:26 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:26 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:28 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:30 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:31 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:31 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:32 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:36 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:37 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:38 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:40 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:40 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:55:41 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1617 points of damage.

Grussum - War - Defender's Guard 3 - AC 17590

Test - max hit I see is 8824 with 1934 being normal

[Sat Jun 13 23:57:32 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:33 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:36 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:38 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:38 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:41 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:41 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:46 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 3312 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:48 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:49 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:49 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 8824 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:50 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:50 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:52 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 7790 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:53 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 1934 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:53 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 8824 points of damage.
[Sat Jun 13 23:57:56 2015] Maestro Tan`Lor crushes YOU for 8824 points of damage.


Client type: SoD
Any 3rd party programs used: MQ2
Bug reproducible on live server: No

Do me a favor and check if defenders guard is working correctly. Does it properly lower dmg intake when active?

Tested on Enomuth

Grussum
AC 18671

No disc, hits for
12637; 3912; 12637; 8710; 3912; 12637; 11328; 3912; 3912; 6093; 8710; 3912; 3912; 12637; 10019;

With disc, hits for
6119; 1894; 1894; 4007; 1894; 6119; 1894; 5274; 1894; 5697; 894; 6119; 4218

I would say yes disc is working. Will test on something else test / live as well.


Avatar of War - No Disc (when I did disc on test the damage went down)
Live -
AC 17534
1185; 1625; 1625; 1625; 1625; 1185; 1625; 1625; 1625; 1625 (Max hit seen 1625)

Test -
AC 17502
1787; 1787; 1787; 1787; 1787; 3437; 2942; 2942; 1617; 1787; 1787; 3437; 2937; 2447; 3025; (Max hit seen 3437)

Just pushed the first of some possible changes, please test and let us know. Should see a significant decrease in hits for maximum values.

Grussum AC 17502
Avatar of War

Hits for:
3437; 1787 (x6); 2035; 1787; 2035; 1787 (x6); 2117; 2447; 1787; 1952; 1787 (x 7); 3107 - so max hit 3437


Maestro (DSK3) - AC 17634 -
Hits for:
No Disc - 3485 (x8); 12804; 3485 (x7); 15288; 3485(x4); 14045; 3485 (x9); 10319; 3485(x7); 10319; -- max hit seen was 15910 which happened after immortality fired a couple more times.

AC 17590 -
Hits for with Defenders Guard 3
8824; 1934 (x3); 4000; 1934 (x3); 3656; 1934 (x12); 6412; 3312; 1934; 3312; 1934; 8824; -- max hit seen was 8824

So slightly better. If possible can you get a DPS average for us? We have a few more planned steps to take for the DMG vs New AC code but need more info to make sure we get the correct adjustments.

Ok, not using a parse program so just me and Excel here --

DSK 3 - Maestro

Test
AC 17458 (no buffs except stronghold aura and immortality) - Defenders Guard 3
Total time: 170 seconds
Total damage: 361321
DPS: 2125.417647
Avg: 2441.358108
Max: 8824
Min: 1934

Test After 2nd adjustment
AC 17458 (no buffs except Immortality and stronghold aura) - Defenders Guard 3

Total Time: 185 seconds
Total Damage: 283999
DPS: 1535.12973
Avg: 1945.19863
Max: 6177
Min: 1354




Live
AC 17534 (no buffs except stronghold aura and immortality) - Defenders Guard 3
Total time: 256 seconds
Total damage: 349272
DPS: 1364.34375

Min / Max / Avg: 1617 - if he hit it was for 1617

Second adjustment has been made, please let us know. The last post that you made Niix was perfect. That is the exact information that we need.

Updated in above post - figured you could look at numbers easier that way.


Are pets treated as NPC's? It seems like their DPS is going down again.

Just a very quick test on Atcho - donor pet, focused, weapons and donor buff

Test - 3min - 4846712 : 26926.2 (max hit 15352 with most hits below 10k)
Live - 3min - 8274201 : 45967.8 (max hit 29106 with most, if not all, hits above 10k)

Niixnec wrote:Updated in above post - figured you could look at numbers easier that way.


Are pets treated as NPC's? It seems like their DPS is going down again.

Just a very quick test on Atcho - donor pet, focused, weapons and donor buff

Test - 3min - 4846712 : 26926.2 (max hit 15352 with most hits below 10k)
Live - 3min - 8274201 : 45967.8 (max hit 29106 with most, if not all, hits above 10k)

Nope, pets were excluded from the changes. I will double check though to make sure. I am assuming this is with the necro donor pet?