Grey wrote:(F-) Prestige quest is very meh. Every server I have seen use an idea like that has made the item a "must have" item which blows cock if you dont enjoy doing the quest.
(A+) Evolving items is pretty pimp because you are just going about your business of leveling and raiding and whatever and the shit continues to get better.
Well, I'll start by saying this...he's looking for a TIME-SINK, that is, a quest/adventure/task/series of quests/etc that drain time for people who feel like they need something to keep them busy if they don't feel like progressing normal content. Evolving items, albeit still a good idea to explore, are not a time-sink. You said it yourself, you can go about your normal business as though nothing has changed, but you'll get a leveled up item instead. Does that sound like something that takes EXTRA time? Certainly, you could waste away time exping just to level the item if your max aa, but in most cases, it wouldn't be an ADDED time-sink.
Also, keep in mind, that the prestige quest is a CONCEPT, and therefore can be modified to fit whatever role the CUSTOM server so chooses. Since we hold the ability to modify it in any way, it's completely and 100% within our ability to prevent the quest from becoming a mandatory part of server progression. I believe I already mentioned that in the original post, if you happened to read all of it...
And, in my opinion, the biggest challenge around the prestige quest concept is the POTENTIAL (not necessarily inevitable) overcrowding of lower and midlevel custom zones to powerlevel through the quest process. But, with the introduction of a smoother transition in tier ranges in the near future (as mentioned by Chaosslayer in another post), and with a parallel set of custom zones (hopefully doubling the options), this won't exactly be a tremendous hindrance. Also, personally, I'd prefer to powerlevel in Scarlet Desert from 1-50 anyway, which is not a custom zone, and it wouldn't bother any of the server newbies. There's plenty more non-custom zones open that are just as good, as well.
There's seriously some great potential to this type of a quest if you are strictly looking for a time-sink...I just think no one has got it right yet. Since THF has gotten everything else (and then some) right, what other servers have yet to do, then why not try a crack at the prestige quest?