The first real agro weapon I had on live was a BBoE, I got lucky every warrior in the first raiding guild I joined already had either a BoC, hategiver, and/or a Bloodfrenzy LOL. No one else wanted it so it went to the new guy. I loved that weapon, and used it for probably half a year before I got better ones. It had crazy agro, and was known to out-aggro BoC easily (although stats were inferior).
Since PoFire is open, I searched on Magelo clone for a novelty weapon that I sorely miss... Obsidian Battle Sword (warrior pet sword that procs epic 1.0s). I camped PoFire for that thing over a month or two till I finally got one LOL. I think there were only 2 other warriors in Maelin Starpyre that had it. Dual-wielded it with a Darkblade of the Warlord and they were pure sex before GoD came out. It was my most prized weapon just because of the proc and rarity. Unfortunately, that pet sword doesn't drop in THF =X
I'd love to see these pet weapons in-game again... maybe boost the stats a little bit to match the server's standards so it won't be useless. Make the drop rate just slightly less rare than in Live (it was too rare LOL). Guaranteed I will camp for one if you guys include this ingame.